Multicultural Issues: Intervention/Prevention in Communities of Color

Vetta Sanders Thompson Ph.D. National Violence Against Women Prevention Research Center

University of Missouri at St. Louis

 

A variety of multicultural concerns affect response to violence against women in communities of color. The unique cultural, social, and economic experiences of each woman must be considered in understanding her response to intimate partner violence. Language, immigration/refugee status, as well as level of acculturation must be considered as prevention and service delivery plans are formulated.

It is important that practitioners, advocates, shelter workers, judicial and legal authorities recognize the diversity within the broad categories discussed. Each African, Asian, Hispanic American and American Indian woman possesses a unique set of generational, national/regional, and cultural experiences that differentiate her from other women of that group (Merchant, 2000; Root, 1996). Overgeneralizations should be avoided. Stereotypes regarding minorities and the tolerance of violence in communities of color should be examined.

Programs for women of color will promote utilization by:

* Developing strong links to community support networks (Bohn, 1998; Valencia & Van Hoorn, 1999).

* Equipping shelters with appropriate grooming aids, toys and reading

material for children and adults that reflects ethnic diversity.

* Providing shelters with food familiar and appealing to individuals from diverse background (Sorenson, 1996; Torres, 1998.

* Presence of workers, advocates, or volunteers of similar ethnicity/background (Bohn, 1998; Merchant, 2000).

* Addressing communication needs.

 

Communication

* Shelters, as well as other institutions, are often unable to provide services or assistance in the preferred language of ethnic minority women (Sorenson, 1996; Root, 1996; Pressman, 1994). Limited English-speaking skills inhibit disclosure and limits the amount of help a victim may seek from police, hospital staff, shelter personnel, or victim advocates (Thomas, 2000).

* Bilingual programs have been developed that overcome these barriers (Valencia & Van Hoorn, 1999).

* Hispanic, Asian, and American Indian women reportedly prefer intervention/treatment personnel to ask directly about domestic violence. They viewed queries and discussions that took place in private and supportive environments more positively. These strategies were seen as contributing to disclosure despite community and cultural taboos (Rodriquez, Bauer, Florez-Ortiz & Szkupinski-Quiroga, 1998; Bohn, 1998).

Immigration Status

* Recent immigrants may fear reporting violence due to INS (Immigration Naturalization Services) involvement and/or deportation.

* A belief that she is dependent on her husband for a green card is an obstacle to leaving an abusive relationship (Merchant, 2000).

* Recent immigrants often lack knowledge about legal rights and assistance resources (Root, 1996; Sorenson, 1996; Pressman, 1994). Shelters that assist in obtaining legal services, particularly those related to immigration status, increase the likelihood that an eligible woman will be able to leave an abusive relationship without jeopardizing her immigration status.

* Undocumented immigrants (Sorenson, 1996; Holtzman, 1994; Pressman, 1994) do not perceive shelters that check or require citizenship as options.

* Immigration may result in the loss of social controls monitoring family activities and leading to increased family violence (Hampton, et. al., 1998; Chester, Robin, Koss, Lopez, & Goldman, 1994). Cultural attitudes may be rigidly observed to maintain a sense of stability and may include patriarchal sex roles, taboos on communicating about infidelity, sexuality, and violence (Sorenson, 1996).

Refugee Status

* Many refugee women of color have experienced the violence and trauma of repressive regimes, and have been particularly vulnerable to sexual violence. Their experience of and reaction to intimate partner violence must be understood in light of exposure to the use of violence by legitimized authority to maintain control. These experiences may result in increased vulnerability to PTSD and depression.

* The unique experiences of women refugees may also affect self-confidence and trust and disclosure and action.

* The additional stress of resettlement in a new culture compounds reactions to prior exposure to violence (Merchant, 2000).

* Women involved in resettlement programs, who seek IPV services, should be screened carefully for these issues (Holtzman, 1994; Pressman, 1994).

Acculturation Issues

* Acculturation level (knowledge of and comfort with host culture) may influence women's attitudes, assertiveness, and responses to domestic violence and rape.

* Men may feel powerless and out of control in the new community. This can affect the adherence to and acceptance of cultural/ social norms governing male/female relations and family roles (Sorenson, 1996; Pressman, 1994).

It is theorized that male refugees use domestic violence as a way to re-establish control and power (Thomas, 2000).

* There may be unique stresses, such as increased intergenerational conflict that can increase family violence (Sorenson, 1996; Pressman, 1994).

Socioeconomic Inequities

Women of color experience higher rates of poverty than European American women, as well as a history of social/political oppression. This reality affects the options they have. Issues of concern include:

* Economic resources to leave relationships that are violent/abusive

* Economic or social reliance on the perpetrator, family and/or community of theperpetrator. These may be due to the desire to complete the citizenship application process, issues of employment due to immigration status, level of education, and English facility.

* Access to transportation or financial ability to travel beyond the neighborhood to seek shelter, services, etc. (Merchant, 2000; Valencia & Van Hoorn, 1999; Sorenson, 1996; Root, 1996;).

* Limited research has suggested the importance of employment counseling, job training, child care assistance, food, housing assistance and legal aid for women of color (Merchant, 2000; Valencia & Van Hoorn, 1999; Bohn, 1998; Sullivan & Rumptz, 1994; Rimonte, 1989).

References

Bohn, D.K. (1998). Clinical Interventions with Native American Battered Women. In J. C. Campbell (Ed.). Empowering Survivors of Abuse: Health care for Battered Women and Their Children (pp. 241 - 258). Thousand Oaks: Sage.

Chester, B., Robin, R. W., Koss, M. P., Lopez, J., Goldman, D. (1994). Grandmother dishonored: Violence against women by male partners in American Indian communities. Violence & Victims, 9, 249-256.

Hampton, R. Carrillo, R. & Kim, J. (1998). Violence in Communities of Color. In. R. Carrillo and J. Tello (Eds.) Family Violence and Men of Color. Healing the Wounded Male Spirit (pp. 1 - 27). New York, NY: Springer Publishing Co.

Holtzman, C. G. (1994). Multicultural Perspectives on Counseling Survivors of Rape. Journal of Social Distress and the Homeless, 3, 81 - 97.

Merchant, M. (2000). A comparative study of agencies assisting domestic violence victims: Does the South Asian community have special needs? Journal of Social Distress and the Homeless, 9, 249-259.

Pressman, B. (1994). Violence against women: Ramifications of gender, class and race inequality, In M. P. Mirkin (Ed.) Women in Context: Toward a feminist reconstruction of psychotherapy (pp. 352 - 389). New York, NY: Guilford Press.

Rimonte, N. (1989). Domestic Violence among Pacific Asians. In Asian Women United of California (Eds.), Making Waves (pp. 327 - 337). Boston: Beacon.

Rodrigez, M. A.; Bauer, H, M.; Flores-Ortiz, Y.; Szkupinski-Quiraga, S. (1998). Factors Affecting Patient-Physician Communication for Abused Latino and Asian Immigrant Women. The Journal of Family Practice, 47, 309 - 311.

Root, M. P. P. (1996). Women of Color and Traumatic Stress in Domestic Captivity: Gender and Race as Disempowering Statuses. In Marcella, A. J.; Friedman, M. J.; Gerrity, D. J. and Scurfield, R. M. (Eds). Ethno-Cultural Aspects of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: Issues, Research, and Clinical Applications (pp. 363 - 387). Washington. DC: American Psychological Association.

Sorenson, S. B. (1996). Violence Against Women: Examining Ethnic Differences and Commonalties. Evaluation Review, 20, 123 - 145.

Sullivan, C. M. & Rumptz, M. H. (1994). Adjustment and needs of African American Women who utilize a domestic violence shelter. Violence and Victims, 9, 275 - 285.

Thomas, E. K. (2000). Domestic violence in the African American and Asian American for mental health service provision for women of color. Psychology: A Journal of Human Behavior, 37, 32-43.

Torres, S. (1998). Intervening with Battered Hispanic Pregnant Women. In J. C. Campbell (Ed.) Empowering Survivors of Abuse: Health Care for Battered Women and Their Children (pp. 259 - 270). Thousand Oaks: Sage Publication.

Valencia, A. & Van Hoorn, J. (1999). La Isla Pacifica: A haven for battered Mexican American women. American Psychologist, 54, 62-63.